Interrupted Innovation: Innovation System Dynamics in Latecomer Aerospace Industries

Author(s): Daaniel Vertesy & Adam Szirmai
Working Paper No.: 2010-02
Keywords: Aerospace manufacturing, sectoral innovation systems, system dynamics, latecomer industrialisation, technological capabilities

In this paper we analyse the role of sectoral innovation systems in the emergence and catch-up of aerospace industries in latecomer economies. We argue that the aerospace sector is characterized by a process of interrupted innovation. Competitive pressures and the cyclical nature of the industry not only require shifts in the direction of innovation and changes in the production system, but also periodical restructuring of the whole sectoral system of innovation. Aerospace manufacturing requires advanced technological capabilities at the earliest stages of the emergence of the industry. Producers immediately need to comply with high international technology, quality and safety standards. Stage models of gradual technological upgrading in the process of catch up are therefore not appropriate to analyse the evolution of this industry in latecomer economies. The model of interrupted innovation developed in this paper provides an alternative perspective. In country case studies of Brazil, China, Indonesia and Argentina, we show how changes in the global competitive landscape and major political developments trigger crises in the industry, with which existing systems of innovation are unable to cope. Competitive pressures periodically require the industry to reinvent itself almost from scratch. We conclude that the emerging economies that have succeeded in catching up in aerospace are those that have established a competitive industrial sector with a sectoral innovation system which is able to adapt flexibly to radically changing circumstances.

The Development of Aerospace Clusters in Mexico

Author(s): Javier Martínez Romero
Working Paper No.: 2010-03
Keywords: Aerospace, cluster, Mexico

High technology companies tend to cluster around knowledge-producing institutions (Braunerhjelm and Feldman, 2006). Aerospace follows this pattern, and there are well known examples of aerospace clusters located around largeprime contracting aerospace producers (Niosi and Zhegu, 2005). A recent trend that is taking momentum is the setting up of manufacturing facilities by leading aerospace companies in Mexico.

Objectives: The objective of this study is to investigate the attracting factors of Mexican clusters and to examine some of the country policy measures to incentive the aerospace sector, in order to assess the potential of Mexico to be a relevant part in this world-class high technology industry.

Methods: A survey applied to selected aerospace firms in Mexico and interviews with regional governments are the information source.

Results: Agglomeration forces in Mexican aerospace clusters are strongly related with manufacturing advantages. In addition, policy measures seem insufficient to encourage firms to undertake more complex activities.

Conclusions: Even though advantages not related with innovation may explain the presence of firms in Mexico’s aerospace clusters, these advantages should not be minimized given the tough quality standards of the aerospace industry, and if properly managed they may form the base for future development.

A policy model to foster coevolutionary processes of science, technology and innovation: the Mexican case

Author(s): Gabriela Dutrénit, Martín Puchet Anyul, Luis Sanz-Menendez, Morris Teubal & Alexandre O. Vera-Cruz
Working Paper No.: 2008-03
Keywords: Coevolution, innovation, science and technology, development, structural change, policies, Mexico, Israel

This paper argues that in the context of the knowledge economy the coevolution of S&T and Innovation is crucial for developing countries. Two features limit such coevolution in this type of countries: (i) the conditions for generating variation, selection and retention (VSR) processes in both arenas are still incipient, there is neither the required size nor the diversity of agents and organizations, and (ii) even though there are links between the agents and functioning structures, they hardly generate bidirectional causal mechanisms. A set of policies is required to stimulate a coevolutionary process of S&T and Innovation; they should focus on the capabilities and institutions that are required for the emergence of the initial conditions and the promotion of new processes.

Drawing on the Systems-Evolutionary Perspective, and based on a comprehensive assessment of the Mexican STI policy 2000-2006, this paper discusses the failures to build virtuous coevolutionary processes of S&T and Innovation and suggests a three stage STI policy design to strengthen the VSR processes and the bidirectional causal mechanisms that contribute to such coevolutive processes.

Discussing innovation and development: Converging points between the Latin American school and the Innovation Systems perspective?

Author(s): José E. Cassiolato & Helena M. M. Lastres
Working Paper No.: 2008-02
Keywords: Development, innovation systems, Latin America

Since it was formulated in the 1980s, the Systems of Innovation approach has been increasingly used in different parts of world to analyze processes of acquisition, use and diffusion of innovations and to guide policy recommendations. In Latin America the structuralism tradition in discussing development developed since the 1950s under the influence of the Economic Commission of Latin America and Caribbean has also highlighted the importance of technical change in systemic terms.

The paper aims at (1) identifying and discussing common aspects, as well as main differences between both approaches; and (2) exploring the advantages of linking these approaches particularly, but not exclusively, in the case of development.

The importance of examining convergences between these frameworks is three fold. First, it contributes to a deeper reflection on the use of the concept of innovation systems in understanding and orienting the processes of innovation and capacity building in less developed countries. Second, we argue that both approaches can benefit a lot from incorporating contributions from each other. Finally, this effort of discussing conceptual coherence may even provide ground to identify convergences when comparing analytical and normative frameworks to be used in national systems of innovation and in development studies not only in the Americas but also in Africa, Asia, Oceania and Europe.

A Vision for Latin America: A resource-based strategy for technological dynamism and social inclusion

Author(s): Carlota Perez
Working Paper No.: 2008-01
Keywords: Policy model, science, technology and innovation, Mexico

This essay looks at the current trends in globalization and in the diffusion of the ICT (Information and Communications Technology) revolution and its paradigm in order to propose a vision of a successful and socially equitable future for Latin America, based on the common features, while harboring all the variety of its countries. It hopes to provide the basis for intensive research and for a serious and wide ranging debate on the matter.

The proposal is rooted in the author‟s work on the diffusion of technological revolutions, on how technology and technological capabilities determine growth potential and on the way in which the world technological context changes the windows of opportunity for development of countries and regions.

It is a suggestion in response to the growing concern among Latin Americans that without an agreed sense of direction it will be very difficult to get onto a dynamic development path. The rising prices of raw materials have indeed provided the fuel for regaining a higher rhythm of growth, but technological capabilities are not growing apace and profound social inequalities persist –often deeper than in the 1970s. The region is becoming aware of the need to provide a solid foundation for a more stable source of economic growth and of social development potential.

Catching Up: What are the critical factors for success?

Author(s): Jan Fagerberg & Martin Srholec
Working Paper No.: 2007-07
Keywords: Catching up, capabilities

This paper addresses one of the oldest and most controversial issues in economics: Why do some countries succeed in catching up, while others fall behind?

In recent years the quality and availability of data on different aspects of development have improved a lot. Attempting to exploit this opportunity for more indepth research the paper starts with an overview and assessment of the different approaches in the literature and the empirical indicators and methods that these have given rise to. This leads to the formulation of a synthetic empirical model and, with the help of factor analysis on large variable set, to the identification of set of “capabilities” which might be assumed to be of critical importance for catch up.

The explanatory power of these capabilities for economic growth is tested on a sample of 135 countries in the 1990s.

Cambios Estructurales y Ciclos de Destruccion y Creacion de Capacidades Productivas y Technologicas en América Latina

Author(s): Jorge Katz
Working Paper No.: 2007-06
Cambios estructurales, capacidades productivas y technologicas, America Latina

Pese a que los programas de apertura comercial externa, des-regulación de mercados y privatización de la actividad productiva fueron aplicados por los distintos países Latinoamericanos en diferentes momentos del tiempo – Chile comenzó sus esfuerzos en este sentido en los años 1970, mientras que Brasil solo lo hizo en los años 1990 – y pese, también, a que hubo avances y retrocesos en la aplicación de los mismos– Chile o Argentina dieron un paso atrás en 1981/82, durante la Crisis de la Deuda, volviendo a levantar aranceles de importación – desde una perspectiva amplia podemos decir que en el curso de las ultimas cinco décadas los países de la región han intentado organizar la actividad económica en base a dos grandes “regímenes” de política publica, de naturaleza casi antagónica.

Social inequality, technology and economic growth

Author(s): Chris Freeman
Working Paper No.: 2007-05
Keywords: Technology, economic development, social inequality, social policy

It is a matter of common observation that inequalities have been increasing in almost every part of the world in the 1980s and 1990s, reversing the more egalitarian trends which prevailed in the early post-war period. This chapter seeks to show: 1) that some alternating phases of retrenchment and egalitarian trends have been characteristic of industrial capitalist societies throughout the 19th and 20th centuries and 2) that these long swings of social policy are related to the diffusion of major new technologies in the economic system. Finally, the chapter discusses very briefly a few of the main directions in which social policy should move if the present inegalitarian trends are to be reversed.

Policies and Institutional Engineering in Developing Economies

Author(s): Mario Cimoli, Giovanni Dosi, Richard R. Nelson & Joseph Stiglitz
Working Paper No.: 2007-04
Keywords: Innovation systems, institutions, policies, technological catching-up, industrial development

The existence of profound relationships of some sorts between innovation, industrialization and economic development is now generally acknowledged in both economic history and economic theory. However, the conditions which foster technological learning and its successful incorporation into the economy and in particular the role of institutions and policies continues to be more controversial. This chapter addresses these issues and tries to offer a framework for the interpretation of the ways activities of “institutional engineering” and policies shape technological catching-up and industrial development.

Institutions, ”Social Technologies”, and Economic Progress

Author(s): Richard R. Nelson
Working Paper No.: 2007-03
Keywords: Institutions, technologies, co-evolution, economic development

This paper aims to put together two strands of economic analysis. One is concerned with technological progress as the key driving force behind economic development. The other is concerned wtith the role of institutions in shaping economic activity, and with how institutions change in the process of economic development. The argument developed in the paper is that technologies and institutions co-evolve.