This study proposes that individual intermediate users in resource-poor environments represent a source of innovation. The paper first surveys the empirical evidence of user innovation in various developing countries and then examines some cases of user innovation in India. On the basis of the cases examined, the paper proposes an appreciative theory and then a formal model of the innovation process by users in a development context. This process is driven by the unmet, low-cost and functional needs of users, users’ contextual know-how and experience, and users’ knowledge of, and ability to learn from, the local context.
Category: All
Chinese Technologies and pro-poor industrialisation in Sub Saharan Africa: The case of furniture manufacturing in Kenya
Despite very rapid growth, absolute poverty levels in sub Saharan Africa (SSA) have remained high. Kenya’s economic performance reflects these wider trends with a relatively high growth, but high levels of poverty and unemployment. These adverse developmental trends are associated with the fact that industrialisation and agricultural mechanisation efforts in SSA economies have largely relied on imported technologies from advanced economies, many of which are unsuited to African factor endowments. This trend is, however, being reversed such that advanced countries are becoming less important as sources of technology for SSA economies while other developing countries, particularly China, are becoming more important sources. Through a case study of Kenya’s furniture industry, this paper seeks to assess whether technologies from China and the developing indigenous capital goods sector in Kenya may help address the development impasse. Drawing on detailed research with more than 100 furniture manufacturers in four clusters and spanning the formal and informal sectors, the paper compares the operating characteristics of Chinese machines, advanced country machines as well as the locally manufactured machines. The findings indicate that Chinese and Kenyan technologies appear more amenable for pro-poor industrialisation and development of SSA economies than those from advanced countries.
Innovative strategies: when path dependence turns into path creation. Innovation and performance in the Argentinean manufacturing sector
This paper analyzes changes in the firm’s innovative strategy and how this impacts firm’s performance. The methodology is based on a cluster analysis over 800 Argentinean manufacturing firms with information from Argentinean Innovation (1998-2006). The period under analysis includes deep changes in the environment and provides good reasons to expect changes in the firms’ strategic behavior. Results show that some firms did change the strategy but some did not. A set of continuous innovative firms sustained a high-profile innovation-oriented strategy, with high productivity gains. Another group of firms also sustained the strategy, but a non-innovative one. Between these groups, a set of new innovative firms changed their strategy and caught up with investments based on high levels of capabilities, and this also led them to high productivity levels. Finally, a set of sporadic innovative firms show an erratic behavior associated with abandoned innovation investments which were not enough to impact firms’ performance. The preliminary conclusion is that understanding how firms’ strategies change over time is a key matter to understand how innovation impacts performance. This challenges path dependence literature and empirical approaches based on averaged innovation trajectories. Findings show that what the firm did on the past can predict only partially what the firm will do in the future. Therefore, there is not an average innovative behavior but heterogeneous responses which lead to different interactions between innovation and performance.
Standardization and Governance Dynamics in the Peruvian Alpaca Fibre Value Chain
This paper examines governance dynamics stemming from standardization in the Peruvian alpaca fibre chain. An empirically informed bi-dimensional framework resembling the chain’s fragmented supply-concentrated demand structure is applied to scrutinize vertical and horizontal interactions among domestic actors and institutions. Findings for the 1997-2013 period show that far from generic buyer-driven or quasi-hierarchical governance typologies, segmented governance modes co-exist but do not co- evolve within the fibre chain as standardization unfolds. Comparative case studies applying the proposed framework are encouraged in similarly structured commodity chains in the developing world for a more comprehensive understanding of governance dynamics.
UNU-MERIT at 25 Years: How Doctoral Training at UNU-MERIT Contributes to the Community of Scholars in the Economics of Innovation?
- This paper contributes to literature on the emergence of innovation studies as a scientific field. This area of research documents the mechanisms, interactions and meeting spaces that innovation scholars have developed to give substance and legitimacy to their work. What role is there for the training of young scholars in the development of this new scientific field?
Based on a web-based survey of UNU-MERIT’s PhD alumni, we explore the ways in which doctoral training at a major research institute has contributed to the formation of young scholars in the broad field of innovation studies. In line with literature on the creation of science and technology human capital, we find that doctoral training grants PhD holders the technical knowledge and skills, together with the relational skills that sustain their membership and scholarly contributions to innovation studies. The evidence likewise suggests that the contribution of UNU-MERIT’s PhD program on the building of innovation research capacities in developing countries is constrained by post-graduate decisions to stay in the developed world. Young scholars follow a career development strategy of linking to mentors and key senior researchers, while scientific interactions with fellow students are more limited. Social interactions tend to be more prominent for maintaining relations with the research community.
Silicon Savanna? Local Competence Building and International Venture Capital in Low Income Countries. The Emergence of Foreign High-Tech Investments in Kenya
- With the beginning of the current decade, Africa’s emergence appears to be a new consensus. In contrast to investments earlier this centure, which had mostly aid-characteristics, we nowadays see some flourishing investment hubs emerging – such as Nairobi in Kenya and Lagos in Nigeria – attracting the attention of global growth-oriented tech-investors.
This development is pioneered by a number of silicon valley venture capitalists. That such investments finally arrived in sub-Saharan Africa is a positive signal, as it suggests that there exist young companies with innovative products, services, or business models which are potentially fit for international or even global markets.
In this paper we investigate the pattern of current technology investments in Kenya – one of sub-Saharan Africa’s buzzing ICT centers. In many cases these financial investments are accompanied by intensive technical and business support. Besides, some of these investors are actively building up networks, and thus, connecting supported companies. This scenario is new for companies and institutions in sub-Saharan Africa and likely to contribute to local capacity building and potentially even catching-up.
We explore this new phenomenon of international high-tech investments, focusing on the case of Kenya. Classifying investors and start-ups, and mapping the interaction structure between them, we aim at identifying investment patterns that can contribute to competence building and sustainable development in less developed economies in the global South. To gather the data required, we are among the first to exploit the rich information and graph-based structure of the CrunchBase dataset to explore technology investments in an economically less developed context.
Social Interactions. A Formal Approach to Feedback-Based Evolutionary Local Learning
This paper discusses the usefulness of SI models in explaining feedback-based local learning. The literature on evolutionary economic geography gives feedbacks a major role in shaping local systems, nevertheless the econometric approaches to local systems are mainly focused on estimating spillovers. Although some works have already proposed to use social interactions models to approach local systems, they have not focused on feedbacks processes involved in local interactions neither have estimated the social multipliers implied. This paper proposes that feedbacks dynamics can be capture estimating social multipliers implicit in social interactions models and by distinguishing between different types of interactions that can give rise to local spillover. In this regard tree different types of interactions are distinguished: 1) pure spillovers or common shocks, 2) self-selection (choosing the location according the characteristics of co-located firms), and 3) pure social interactions (when the behavior of co-located firms affect individual behavior). Feedbacks will be present in the last two types. This distinction will be used for detecting feedbacks from pure spillovers, in which most of the literature has focused. Although the objective of this paper is to explore a methodology and to discuss its scope, in the last section the paper offers an estimation of social multipliers in local systems made up by SMEs that share the same industry and geographical localization. This estimation is run in a microdatabase compound by 1233 Argentinean SMEs with information on productivity and innovation behavior among other variables for the period 2006 -2008. The results show positive and significant social multipliers and that cannot be the result of pure spillover. Therefore, the results offer statistical evidence that support the hypothesis of feedbacks in local interactions.
A Green and Socially Equitable Direction for the ICT Paradigm
This paper takes up Chris Freeman’s challenge of facing the environmental limits with science, technology and innovation in order to keep open the possibilities of the developing world along a sustainable “green” growth path. It analyses the differences between the energy intensive paradigm of mass production and consumerism in mid-20th Century and the potential shift to sustainability generally provided by the ICT revolution. It then focuses on the developing world and examines the changes in the global market context that are creating windows of opportunity for local innovation, social inclusion and green growth. It finally discusses the alliances and conditions for taking full advantage of the available transformative potential.
Innovation Systems and Development: the use of the IS framework along the first ten years of the Globelics conference
This paper analyzes how the innovation system (IS) framework has been used for addressing development issues. It is based on a review of 1461 papers from the last nine Globelics conferences. We found a rich set of contributions focusing on different dimensions of innovation systems and a growing importance of research lines that link a systemic perspective with issues that are relevant for national and local social-economic development processes that are sustainable and inclusive. There is a great potential for deepening some research lines, especially those in connection with the rich development thinking traditions that evolved in less developed countries, helping to enrich the IS framework and policy agenda.
Learning through the International Joint Venture: Lessons from the Experience of China’s Automotive Sector
International joint ventures may only lead to partial success in nurturing local technological capability. In the existence of a substantial technological-capability gap between alliance partners, the international joint venture arrangement is likely to create a “passive” learning mode where teachers determine what, when and how learners should learn. This study presents a detailed case study of Shanghai-Volkswagen and Shanghai-General Motors which are often considered two of the most successful Sino-foreign auto-assembly joint ventures.
